Carbon monoxide CO: an exception to Kekulé’s fixed valence theory

The existence of the CO molecule challenged Kekulé's fixed valence theory of carbon.

by Roberto Poeti

A Student Question about Carbon Monoxide.

It’s likely that when presenting the fixed valence theory of an element, supported by Kekulé, a teacher might encounter an attentive student who asks how Kekulé dealt with the position of carbon in carbon monoxide in relation to the fixed valence, four, that he attributed to carbon in all its compounds. I tried to answer the hypothetical curiosity of the student.

Positions on valence

It was not easy to reconstruct Kekulé’s position on this problem. References to carbon monoxide CO regarding its anomalous valence are almost absent. The impression is that Kekulé wanted to avoid the problem, especially he avoids comparison with the positions of Archibald Scott Couper:

“Affinity of degree are the degrees, or also the limits of combination, that elements show. For example, C2O2 and C2O4 are the degrees of affinity of carbon for oxygen. C2O2 can be called the first degree, and C2O4 can be defined as the second degree, and, since a higher degree than this is not known for carbon, its ultimate affinity or limit of combination [maximum valence]. The affinity of degree in an element can have only one degree. It can, however, and generally has more than one.”

And Edward Frankland:

“The number of bonds possessed by an element, or its atomicity, is not apparently—at least—a fixed and invariable quantity”

 which considered carbon, that model of constant valence of Kekulé, as divalent (a dyad) in carbon monoxide and as tetravalent (a tetrad) in carbon dioxide.

Archibald Scott Couper

Friedrich August Kekulé

Scientific Identity, Portrait of Edward Frankland

The sources
There are two sources from which to draw references on the anomaly of carbon in carbon monoxide. They are found in Annalen der Chemie und Pharmacie from 1858 with an article “On the constitution and metamorphoses of chemical compounds and on the chemical nature of carbon”; and in the first volume of his treatise Lehrbuch der Organischen Chemie oder der Chemie der Kohlenstoffverbindungen 1861 – “Manual of Organic Chemistry or the Chemistry of Carbon Compounds.” In the article in Annalen, Kekulé establishes for the first time that carbon has a single valence of four, conceives the bonds between carbon-carbon in organic molecules, and derives the general formula for hydrocarbons: If more than two carbon atoms bond in the same way, for each additional atom the basicity of the carbon group increases by two units. The number of hydrogen atoms (chemical units) bonded to n carbon atoms arranged in this way, for example, is then expressed as: n(4-2)+2 = 2n+2. The bonds between carbon atoms are not yet represented graphically. Around the same period, Archibald Scott Couper also hypothesized the C-C bonds, and for the first time used dashes and dotted lines to connect the symbols of carbon atoms, basically inventing the structural formulas we still use today. Couper, unlike Kekulé, didn’t believe that carbon had only one valence, but also a valence of two, as in carbon monoxide.

The radicals

Kekulé is anchored to a representation of structure that originates from Berzelius’ theory of radicals. Berzelius’ radicals were atomic blocks that behaved like elements, remaining unchanged in reactions. The Typological theory developed by Charles Gerhardt and Alexander Williamson created a different radical, a dynamic and modifiable organic group. For both Gerhardt and Williamson (and later for Kekulé), during a chemical reaction (then called a “metamorphosis”), a molecule undergoes a double decomposition. In this process, some atoms of the original radical can be torn away and replaced by others. The atomic group changes composition, but what remains continues to occupy the same “place” within the reference chemical type (like the Water Type). Atomicity was born in embryo in the Typological theory. It actually allowed grouping organic compounds and their “residues” (or radicals) based on how they replaced hydrogen atoms within four reference inorganic models (Types). For example, in the Water Type (H2O), a monovalent radical replaced just one hydrogen (forming an alcohol), while an atom or radical capable of bonding to both hydrogens implicitly introduced the idea of a different combining capacity. Kekulé expanded the number of Types by adding methane.

Alexander Williamson

Charles Gerhardt

Radicals and Valence
The breakthrough made by Kekulé, however, is to turn attention to the constitution of radicals, that is, to the elements that make them up. The atomicity of a radical is the result of the atomicity of its elementary components:

………..I believe it is necessary and, given the current state of chemical knowledge, in many cases possible, to explain the properties of chemical compounds by going back to the very elements that make up these compounds. I don’t consider the main problem of the time to be demonstrating the presence of atomic groups that, based on specific properties, can be considered as radicals, and thus refer to compounds of a few types, which hardly have any meaning beyond simple formula schemes. On the contrary, I believe that we need to extend our investigation to the constitution of the radicals themselves; that we need to determine the relationship of radicals to one another and, from the nature of the elements, deduce both the nature of the radicals and that of their compounds. …….

In the chapter Constitution of Radicals, the focus on the elemental composition of radicals and compounds is explicitly highlighted with vigor, and there are notable new points, as we will soon see:

……. The simplest radicals themselves are aggregations of single atoms of elements, which follow exactly the same laws that generally apply to the aggregation of atoms. So, one can talk about the composition of radicals in the same way one talks about the composition of compounds. The way individual atoms are arranged within radicals depends, just like the aggregation of atoms in the simplest compounds (§. 190 et seq.), on the nature and especially the basicity of the atoms. A monobasic atom, for instance, can only join with another monobasic atom and apparently only in a specific way. Dibasic atoms, on the other hand, can already show greater variety in aggregation. An atom of a diatomic element can, for example, connect with another atom of a diatomic element so that the two affinity units of one atom are linked to the two affinity units of the other. The oxygen molecule, for instance, is such an aggregation of two atoms. However, two atoms of a diatomic element or of two different diatomic elements can also combine in such a way that only one of the two affinity units of one atom is linked to one of the other. Of the four affinity units of the two dibasic atoms, therefore, 2 are used to hold the atoms together, leaving two that can still bond via affinity with other atoms. The atomic group thus shows, since it is able to form a bond with two monobasic atoms, the behavior of a diatomic radical. When three dibasic atoms combine in the same way, that is, so that one affinity unit of one atom always bonds with one of the other, an atomic group is formed in which of the six affinity units of the atoms, four are used to join the three atoms themselves; for example, the SO2 group (Sulfuryl) is a diatomic radical, meaning it still has two affinity units available; it bonds, for instance, with 2 chlorine atoms to produce chlorosulfuric acid SO2.Cl₂ or substitutes two H atoms in two water molecules (that is, satisfying the two affinity units that were previously saturated by the two hydrogen atoms) and thus produces the hydrate of sulfuric acid *).

What is the valence of a radical? Kekulé calls valence in various ways—affinity, basicity, atomicity—but for the first time, he shows that the valence of a radical is the result of the valence of its atomic components. In doing this, he applies his idea of the fixed valence of an element. In fact, if the SO2 radical has a valence of two (as shown by the compound SO2.Cl2), this is the result of the valence two of sulfur and two of oxygen. To form a stable atomic group, whether a radical or a compound, the atoms must each share a valence with each other (one unit of affinity from one atom binds to one from the other). So the three atoms of the SO2 radical must engage four valences for their cohesion, and the remaining two are the ones that show up as a radical. It’s worth noting that he doesn’t make hypotheses about the way they bond, for example:

A leap forward

But a note from Kekulé himself at the end of the paragraph on the constitution of radicals highlights what is maturing in his conception of the interatomic bond. It is the first time a molecular structure appears: *) This arrangement of atoms can be made more understandable through a graphic representation, showing the basicity of atoms with different sizes. A difference in size that therefore does not express the actual different size of the atoms, but only indicates the number of chemical units an atom represents, that is, the number of hydrogen atoms it is equivalent to. The following examples are understandable without further comments.

Kekulé didn’t comment on the structure of these molecules, which is a consequence of the atoms’ valence. Those two-dimensional drawings were just simple graphic tools to illustrate valence (the units of affinity). In fact, he talks about the exchange of double affinity between two oxygen atoms without it having any consequences on the bonds between the atoms. The same goes for carbon monoxide CO, which he considers a radical with valence two (for reactions like CO.Cl2), implicitly allowing a double affinity exchange there as well. Basically, a one-to-one relationship between atoms hasn’t been fully pinpointed yet, so you can’t really talk about double and single bonds. Kekulé had insights and made progress, but still without a full awareness of the consequences of his own assumptions.

The existence of CO
Going back to the question we started from, carbon monoxide is a radical with a residual valence of two, because carbon has a valence of four and oxygen two. CO is also seen as the radical of carbonic acid, CO.O. By analogy with CO, consider methylene CH2 as another radical with a residual valence of two, whose existence is thought to be possible, even if it has not yet been isolated (it was known for example in compounds like CH2Cl2, CH2S, and in dioximethylene, which stands for formic aldehyde). The carbonyl radical = CO can be considered like methylene CH2, whose hydrogen has been replaced by an equivalent amount of oxygen. The arrangement of carbon compounds analogous to CO is completed with the definition of the CS radical, thiocarbonyl. By analogy with the carbonyl radical CO, we have CS.S and CS.Cl2. Kekulé managed to organize the world of organic molecules based on the assumption that carbon always showed a valence of four, and that individual atoms in an isolated state are not possible, nor are compounds in which part of the affinity of the atoms forming the bond is not satisfied by the affinity of other atoms. In other words, he made possible (or probable) only closed molecules; that is, those in which all the affinities of individual atoms are linked to each other. The existence of molecules like CO and radicals, in general, is thus temporary. They are open molecules that tend to saturate their valences to form closed molecules. The existence of radicals and the resulting representation of molecules with type theory is therefore also a way to represent molecules like CO and others that are not canonical, that is, closed, avoiding the problem of variable valence. I think this is also where his difficulty in conceiving molecular structures with explicit representations of bonds between atoms comes from.

 

Articoli Correlati

Lascia un commento

Ho letto la policy privacy e accetto il trattamento dei miei dati personali

;